Lexington’s School Board Election Takes Unexpected Turn with Candidate’s Ongoing Lawsuit

Lexington’s School Board Election Heats Up with a Twist of Legal Trouble

What’s Happening in Lexington?

In a surprising twist of events, the school board election in Lexington has taken a rather intriguing turn. Meet Dana Homesley, a candidate vying for one of four available seats on the Lexington 1 school board. In a move that has set the local political scene buzzing, Homesley has an active lawsuit against the very board she hopes to join!

The Lawsuit Background

This legal drama traces back to a heated debate that took place back in November 2021. At that board meeting, Homesley attempted to present an email written by former board member Jada Garris, who had some less-than-flattering things to say about the management of several construction projects in the district. Garris, as history tells, tried to add her email to the board’s official minutes. However, her attempts were thwarted. The board chair, Anne Marie Green, informed Homesley that sharing criticisms of staff during public inputs was against school board policy.

What Happened Next?

When Homesley took to the microphone to dive into the criticisms, she was abruptly cut off by Green, citing the rule against discussing specific staff members in public comments. “We have chosen to prevent what you are trying to do right now, which is enter information about a staff member into the record,” Green told her and swiftly curtailed Homesley’s speaking time.

The Legal Claims

Homesley’s got some backbone, as she stands her ground claiming that her First Amendment rights were violated. In her lawsuit, she contends that the email and its contents were merely objective criticisms of the board’s performance and not personal attacks against any individual. Her attorney, Tyler Rody, argues that this policy leads to what’s called viewpoint discrimination. Notably, she points out that other speakers who provided more favorable comments about district employees were given the floor without any interruptions.

The Board’s Defense

In the thick of this legal tussle, Green’s legal team responded by arguing that she was simply enforcing the board’s existing policies. They also tossed in a technical argument, claiming Homesley’s lawsuit is barred by the statute of limitations since she didn’t act quickly following the 2021 incident. Seems like a game of legal ping-pong!

What’s at Stake?

With the election just around the corner—scheduled for Tuesday, by the way—Homesley remains in limbo. She’s trying to figure out whether she should proceed with her lawsuit if she ends up winning a spot on the board. Can you imagine the drama if she does? The idea of joining a board that she is simultaneously suing makes for quite the cliffhanger!

Why It Matters

The Lexington 1 school board oversees a massive 31 schools and serves about 27,000 students in the community. This makes the election not just about individual candidates but about the future of education in that corner of Lexington County. With Green stepping down after this election, homesley’s potential win adds another layer of complexity to an already volatile situation.

The Community’s Reaction

Locals are on the edge of their seats as they watch this unfold. Some see it as a brave stand for free speech within the educational system, while others worry about the implications of a board member embroiled in such controversial legal matters. As the community prepares to cast its votes, it’s clear that this isn’t just about picking board members—it’s about the principles of open dialogue and accountability, all packed into a neat political package.

The Road Ahead

Will Homesley be able to advocate for change from the inside, or will her legal battles overshadow her political ambitions? Only time will tell. Make sure to stay tuned to see how this story continues to develop—there’s bound to be more twists and turns!