Court Hearing Puts Jay’s Bar and Grill’s Liquor License at Risk Amid Underage Drinking Violations

COLUMBIA, SC – A Bar’s Future Hangs in the Balance

As the sun peeks through patchy fog on this cloudy November morning, a chill fills the air, but not just from the weather. The atmosphere surrounding Jay’s Bar and Grill in The Vista is thick with tension. A recent court hearing took place over the bar’s potential liquor license suspension, and depending on the judge’s ruling, patrons might find themselves looking for a new spot to unwind.

Since its opening in January 2023, Jay’s has had a checkered past, accumulating a staggering number of violations, particularly concerning underage drinking. According to court testimonies from October 29, the establishment has faced numerous citations for allowing under-21 customers to both enter and purchase alcohol, leading to a dire situation for the bar.

Trouble in Paradise

At the recent hearing, attorney Dana Krajack, representing the state’s Department of Revenue, painted a grim picture of the bar. “This is a troubled location,” she stated, emphasizing its design as more of an underage hangout rather than a compliant establishment willing to follow the rules.

Attorneys for Jay’s contend that they are taking steps to remedy the situation, with attorney John Alphin defending the establishment’s actions post-violation. “They’ve done everything they can possibly do to mitigate these events,” he argued. “Just like in Five Points, every once in a while, these things are going to happen.”

Underage Operations

The court proceedings delved deep into specific incidents, including a noteworthy operation by the State Law Enforcement Division (SLED) last December. An underage informant gained entry without her ID being scanned, which is against state regulations. After being allowed to stay, she was sold a beer in clear violation. This incident was part of the approximately 80 citations issued to the bar for minors in possession of alcohol or using fake IDs.

With such a high number of violations, it’s no wonder that the bar has gained a somewhat notorious reputation in the area. Investigator Michael Crowley from the Columbia Police Department expressed concerns over the bar’s appeal to a younger crowd, including college and even high school students. The police have responded to incidents of overcrowding and fights at the bar, further reinforcing concerns about its management.

Changes on the Horizon

Despite the troubling background, Alphin insisted that major changes have been implemented since the December incident. They’ve upgraded ID scanners, increased surveillance with more security cameras, improved staff training, and introduced wristbands for patrons over the age of 21. General manager Michael Hyland acknowledged the previous shortcomings, stating, “We absolutely own that we made a mistake.”

However, even with these changes, law enforcement officials remain skeptical. “If they’re using this scanner and doing what they say they’re doing, this stuff wouldn’t still be happening,” Krajack rebutted, highlighting ongoing issues even after the bar has seemingly turned a new leaf.

The Waiting Game

As the court processes continue, the judge overseeing the case, Robert Reibold, has yet to announce a ruling. The state has pushed for a 45-day suspension, while Jay’s attorneys are advocating for a lesser penalty in the form of a monetary fine. Alphin suggested a $25,000 fee instead, arguing it would be more fitting than shutting the bar down temporarily.

The current liquor license for Jay’s is set to expire on November 12, adding urgency to the situation. Whatever the outcome, the bar’s future hangs in the balance, contingent on the decisions of those in power.

For now, patrons might savor their time at Jay’s while they can, hoping that the bar can indeed turn around its fortunes and create a safer environment to enjoy good food and drinks together.